Click here to send us your inquires or call (852) 36130518

Climate Status Investigations
Department of Energy
National Energy Technology Laboratory
home Curriculum Grid
Resources Week 1 Week 2 Week 3 Week 4 Extensions

Language Arts Connection #3

Language Arts Connection #1

Language Arts Connection #2

Language Arts Connection #3

Language Arts Connection #4

Language Arts Connection #5


20. Selling Solutions to NETL

Optional Extension:

The Great Climate Change Debate

Advocate Debate
| Skeptic Debate

Introduction to scientific models | Optional Extensions & Language Arts

Links on this page: The Politics of Climate Change - Should we trust a novelist on global warming? | Questions for Thought – Student Sheet

National Education Standards Met:

language discipline

Objective: To give insight to students about why sources may be biased and that data can be used in fiction and to back-up both sides of any argument.

Goal: Students will:

  • Read and comprehend the article.
  • Use questions for thought to consider the content they have read.

Standards met: LA1, LA3, LA4, LA6, LA7


  • In class or as a homework assignment have students read the following article from The San Francisco Chronicle.
  • Then have students read the excerpts (or a few selections) from the novel ‘State of Fear” by Michael Crichton.

Page 91 – Page 100
Page 406 – Page 425
Page 463 – Page 470
Appendix 1 Page 630 – Page 638

  • Ask students to respond verbally or in written form to the questions for thought and or comprehension questions.


  • Class discussion questions and/or written comprehension and questions for thought.

back to top


The Politics of Climate Change
Should we trust a novelist on global warming?

- Sandy Tolan, John Harte
Tuesday, November 15, 2005

Tonight at the Hotel Nikko in San Francisco, members of the Platinum Circle of the Independent Institute will have the privilege, at $10,000 per table, to hear a fiction writer talk about one of the pressing issues of our time: global warming. "State of Fear," the latest techno thriller by Michael Crichton, author of the science-fiction fantasy "Jurassic Park," inspired the theme of this evening's talk, "States of Fear: Science or Politics?"

If you belong to the Platinum Circle, or to the lesser Gold or Silver Circles -- or simply paid $25 as a member of the Independent Institute or World Affairs Council, co-sponsors of the event -- expect the author and a "panel of distinguished scientists" to lash out at the widely accepted notion among the vast majority of scientists that human activity is contributing to a warming planet, and that business as usual -- doing nothing about rising levels of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere -- will make things worse.

The Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change, a U.N.-sponsored group of more than 2,000 scientists from more than 100 countries, has concluded that human activity is a key factor in elevated carbon-dioxide levels and rising temperatures and sea levels that could prove catastrophic for tens of millions of people living along Earth's coastlines. In 2003, the American Geophysical Union, an international scientific research group with more than 35,000 members, declared, "Human activities are increasingly altering the Earth's climate." Similar declarations came from the American Meteorological Society, the American Academy for the Advancement of Science and the National Academy of Sciences.

These conclusions underscore research by Naomi Oreskes, a science historian at UC San Diego, who reviewed 928 abstracts of peer-reviewed articles on climate change published in scientific journals between 1993 and 2003 and could not find a single one that challenged the scientific consensus that human-caused global warming is real.

Crichton has read a lot about global warming for his latest novel. So he says in the author's note to "State of Fear." He acknowledges that "Atmospheric carbon dioxide is increasing, and that human activity is the probable cause." He also agrees that the planet is warming, but argues that because part of this is due to natural cycles, "Nobody knows how much of the present warming trend might be man-made," and that therefore, "Before making expensive policy decisions on the basis of climate models, I think it is reasonable to require that those models predict future temperatures accurately for a period of 10 years. Twenty would be better." That requirement is equivalent to mandating that the medical profession predict exactly which smokers will develop lung cancer before subjecting the tobacco companies to health-protecting regulations. As a physician, Crichton should know better.

Crichton's position is increasingly in the minority. In the face of the overwhelming conclusions of scientists, he has placed himself in the bizarre position of comparing them to those in the racist eugenics movement, which drew "support from leading scientists, politicians, and celebrities around the world" during its heyday in the early 20th century before it was discredited. Crichton's implication is that something similar will happen with climate change. But if he wants to equate bad science with what people widely believe, why not attack the statement that the Earth is round, or the theory that matter is composed of atoms? Given the author's odd comparison, one wonders why the respected World Affairs Council would choose to sponsor Crichton's presentation, and sign onto publicity calling "State of Fear" "a landmark, both cautionary and prophetic." Its policy forums would be put to better use by understanding why Crichton is the darling of the global-warming skeptics, and why the work of those skeptics is often funded by Exxon and other energy companies.

For his part, the millionaire author, cocooned by an ever-shrinking group of scientists, uses his minority position to cast himself as a brave man shouting into an ill wind. "Everyone has an agenda," he writes in "State of Fear." "Except me." This is a strange statement for a man who accepted an invitation to testify from Sen. James M. Inhofe, the Oklahoma Republican who is heavily supported by oil and gas interests, and who asked on the Senate floor: "Could it be that man-made global warming is the greatest hoax ever perpetrated on the American people?" In the next breath, the senator answered his own question: "It sure sounds like it." At the Sept. 28 hearing of the Senate's Environment and Public Works Committee, chaired by Inhofe, a puzzled Sen. James Jeffords, independent of Vermont, asked, "Why are we having a hearing that features a fiction writer as our key witness?" One answer: Despite his claim to the contrary, Crichton's "wait 20 years" recommendation is highly political, and in perfect synch with the senator from Oklahoma.

Crichton's political agenda, hidden behind his shroud of pseudoscientific "impartiality," is a convenient distraction for what is clearly a deeper motive. Fess up, Dr. Crichton, you're a writer of "pulse-pounding" novels. Tonight at the Hotel Nikko, tell the truth to the Platinum Circle: You want to sell as much fiction as possible.

Sandy Tolan teaches international reporting at the Graduate School of Journalism at UC Berkeley. John Harte is a professor in the Energy and Resources Group at UC Berkeley. Together they teach "Early Signs," a reporting project examining the social, political and economic impact of global climate change.

back to top

Questions for Thought – Student Sheet


  1. After reading the first opinion article from the San Francisco Chronicle what did you think of the writer Michael Crichton and his novel “State of Fear” ?


  1. After reading the excerpts from the novel “State of Fear” what do you think of the novelist?


  1. Why may your opinion have changed?


  1. How were your opinions on climate change affected by reading the excerpts from the novel? Please give examples.


  1. What can you infer about certain ways that data is represented by the information in the readings from the novel and the information you have been gathering in your investigation into Global Climate Change?


  1. Can you identify where the background information you had previous to studying global climate change came from?


  1. After reading the excerpts from the novel how are you feeling about credible and non-credible sources?

back to top

The Keystone Center Keystone, CO Office
1628 Sts. John Road
Keystone, CO 80435
Phone: 970-513-5800
Fax: 970-262-0152
Denver, CO Office
1580 Lincoln Street
Suite 1080
Denver, CO 80203
Phone: 303-468-8860
Fax: 303-468-8866
Washington, DC Office
1730 Rhode Island Avenue, NW
Suite 509
Washington, DC 20036
Phone: 202-452-1590
Fax: 202-452-1138


IT Support| POS label| System Integration| Software development| label printing| QR code scanner| wms| vending machine| barcode scanner| SME IT| it solution| rfid tag| rfid| rfid reader| it outsourcing| IRLS| inventory management system| digital labelling| barcode label| Self Service Kiosk| Kiosk| Voice Picking| POS scanner| POS printer| System Integrator| printing labels| Denso| inventory management| warehouse management| Point of sale| Business service| vending| mobile app development| terminal handheld| printer hong kong| thermal printer| thermal label printer| qr code scanner online mobile| qr code scanner download| mdm| mobile solutions| mdm solutions| mobile device management|

banner| Backdrop| Bannershop| Ebanner| Eprint| foamboard| hk print| hong kong printing| Printing| backdrop| print100|

electric bike| best electric bike| electric bikes for adults| e bike| pedal assist bike| electric bikes for sale| electric bike shop| electric tricycle| folding electric bike| mid drive electric bike| electric trike| electric mountain bike| electric bicycle| electric bike review| electric fat bike| fat tire electric bike| women's electric bike |

Property Agent| Hong Kong Office Rental| office building| Commercial Building| Grade A Office| Rent Office| office for sale|

Central Plaza| The Centrium| LHT Tower| China Building| AIA Central| Crawford House| Exchange Tower| AIA Tower| World Wide House| One Kowloon| The Gateway | One Island South| Jardine House| Millennium City | Exchange Square| Times Square | Pacific Place| Admiralty Centre| United Centre| Lippo Centre| Shun Tak Centre| Silvercord| The Center| Mira Place| Ocean Centre| Cosco Tower| Harcourt House| Cheung Kong Center|

private school hong kong| English primary school Hong Kong| primary education| top schools in Hong Kong| best international schools hong kong| best primary schools in hong kong| school day| boarding school Hong Kong|

Mailchimp|​​​​​​​ Hubspot| Sendinblue| ActiveCampaign| Aweber| benchmark| SMS|